Back to Podcasts

The Bottom-Up Revolution

A Trauma Surgeon's Case for Safer Streets

Hospitals have become remarkably good at treating crash victims, but what would it take to prevent those injuries altogether? Trauma surgeon Matt Schaeffer spends his working days caring for people after serious injuries, including those caused by traffic crashes. Schaeffer believes safer street design deserves a bigger place in public health, especially when so much medical effort goes into treating harm that might have been prevented in the first place. Yet even among medical professionals, the conversation can quickly turn to individual behavior rather than the conditions that make a crash so dangerous.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  0:06

Hello and welcome to Bottom Up Shorts. I'm Norm with Strong Towns, and I am delighted to be able to connect with so many people that are all, in their own way, seeking to bring about the change that we need to see in our communities. Changes that help our communities heal changes that help our communities really recognize that, like we can provide a great place for everyone to be able to live a good life in a prospering place.

And so, I'm delighted to be joined by Matt Schaeffer today. Matt is going to be one of our speakers at the Civic Leader Summit, which at the time of this recording is coming up next week, and he is a trauma surgery and critical care fellow at Washington University or Barnes-Jewish Hospital in St. Louis, Missouri. Welcome to Bottom Up Shorts, Matt.

Matt Schaeffer  0:49

Hey, thanks for having me. It's a pleasure to be here.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  0:52

Let's dive in. You work as a trauma surgeon in a critical area of delivering care, and you've also gotten connected with Strong Towns. Let's talk about that. What's the connection? How is that sort of maturing in your life?

Matt Schaeffer  1:08

Yeah, I think to make a long story short, I had planned on going to medical school and becoming a doctor from a pretty young age, and it was actually in my time in between undergrad and medical school, I was doing clinical research in Chicago and realized that was my first time living in a big city and living without a car, and realized that it was actually a lot more pleasant than a lot of the things that I had been that I had thought and that I had been told growing up in suburbia, and so that kind of shifted my perspective on what a city should be and what urbanism is, or introduced me to urbanism. And I brought that into medical school, and then just from here being introduced to Strong Towns and hearing about some of the things that Richard Jackson was teaching with his work at the CDC and how important the built environment is to health and to health outcomes, it struck me as a really interesting public health measure that I was surprised more people weren't talking about.

And then I ended up falling in love with surgery and going into surgical residency, I wanted to go somewhere where I could, bike to work. And I was in Dayton, Ohio, and in the early days, they were early in implementing some of their bike lanes, and they had like just introduced their first parking protected bike lane. And obviously, there was some public confusion of people parking in it, and so like any mature adult, I took a picture of it and ranted about it on social media.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  2:49

Yeah,

Matt Schaeffer  2:50

And I was fortunate to have a mentor at Wright State, Dr. Seaman, who was like, "Hey, that actually is an interesting public safety, potential like violence injury prevention thing that we can work on, and that's actually a pretty big, pretty big field of study within trauma surgery. And I was like, hey, this might be a really good opportunity for me to kind of merge some of the things that I spend a lot of time thinking about outside of my practice and outside of my professional development, or in conjunction with my professional development, so found that I was able to merge those and really, put to practice the things that I'm doing on a daily basis in work.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  3:35

And you must see this on our streets all the time that people are really exposed to a significant level of threat, and we have to grapple with what we have done to our streets. We had a Strong Towns member, Josh, in Littleton, Colorado, and he made the point. He said, back in the day, the suburbs, even as they were being newly created, those streets were understood to be shared, and then over time, that consensus began to slip, and they became auto-dominated spaces, or almost exclusively for the automobile.

And the result is that people actually could no longer navigate those spaces safely. Can you share just some of your like? I mean, you are experiencing it as you have to operate on somebody that's been struck and hit by a vehicle, being driven by someone in a way that at times you're like I don't care who's to blame. I just need to find a way to make this stop. Touch on some of those challenges that you see in your community.

Matt Schaeffer  4:30

Yeah, I think that's exactly right. It's not our job to place blame on anyone, right? We're we're not a court of law. We receive someone who comes into the hospital needing help, and we have to figure out first off what all is going on that needs to be addressed, and then second off what steps can we take to try to help them or try to at least stop the harm that is actively happening, because as we'll talk about at the Civic Leader Summit, the injury is kind of the first part, but then the body responds in this really impressive, really incredible way that we have to work with and against sometimes, and it really you see all kinds of all kinds of injuries and injury patterns that lend themselves to different types of interventions and problems down the road.

That I think a lot of times in these discussions we feel that we know the statistics and we hear so many people die from car crashes or things of that nature, and then more recently we've realized okay, for every death there are up to 20 or so injuries or serious injuries and people who become debilitated from traffic violence. And then when you're on the other side of it, where we are, and you actually see what that looks like and what that hospital care and hospital course, and even down the road when we're seeing folks in clinic for several months as they're trying to recover and they have long, like chronic pain issues and wounds that are having a hard time healing, you're like, man, this is a lot of work, and wouldn't it be nice if we just didn't have this happen in the first place?

And then on the other side of things, being a vulnerable road user myself, someone who prefers to walk or bike to work, and seeing the threats that I think a lot of people, when they're behind the windshield or behind the wheel, aren't as aware of, or don't actually feel on a visceral level, I think radicalizes you a little bit just to be really sensitive to that, and sensitive to the way that we've built things in favor of one mode of transportation over others.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  6:49

And it certainly feels like we're doing a lot in terms of like the immediate aftermath. We try to just figure out how do we stabilize the patient, how do we help with this. But I think like you said, there's so much that has to go into prevention and then recovery, and those are two areas that probably need more focus. and it also brings to mind, now an individual has been hurt, but all oftentimes like a community actually bears a wound.

And I think we are bearing a lot of wounds, and one of the ways in which we cope with that is just by like turning a blind eye to it or trying to just like move on, and that feels like what you know. We talk about like carnage on our streets, and we have the numbers to show it, and yet people are just like, "Well, what do you expect us to do? Drive slower?" It's like actually, no. Well, yes, but also there's a reason in which I wrote an article for our site that was like, "Large trucks need better street design if they're a big truck and they're maneuvering down a road, and it feels like they should be going a speed that we don't want them to be going, we should change the street so that way then that vehicle drives at a speed that is more suitable.

And yeah, so I'm really interested in all of the layers of the presentation they are going to be giving in Pensacola and those efforts that are there. But can you connect it, so clearly to the work that you're doing? But you mentioned that in the early days, you actually took in a Strong Towns Curbside Chat. And do you want to share just like there's the things you have to do within the trauma room, but then also outside of that, kind of how has that sort of taken hold for you as you walk and navigate your community?

What are some of the things that you see that you think others can definitely pick up on too?

Matt Schaeffer  8:24

Yeah, so again, kind of going back to Chicago, architecture is very big there. So I always found myself kind of perusing some of the development proposals, and they were kind of redoing the Lakefront Trail while I was there to build, kind of build out the separated pedestrian and bike kind of surfaces, and I remember reading on like one of these architecture blogs there was this big skyscraper proposed, and some like the most common complaint about it was the parking podium.

They're like, this thing has way too much parking, and it was just something I had never really thought about. And so, being a being a nerd, I was like, what do you mean? And then it dawned on me: hey, I moved to Chicago and did not bring a car because I couldn't afford the parking, and I found it not to be a restriction at all because of because of the city layout and because of the public transportation, I was able to get pretty much anywhere I wanted in the city at any time at a fixed rate that would have been less than the cost of car maintenance.

And so then is that was like one of I guess one of the flashpoints were. I was like, "Huh, interesting." And along that discussion were some mentions of Strong Town. So that was when I first started reading, like, "Okay, what, what, what is this? What does it mean?" And I think Strong Towns and Chuck Marohn, to his credit, really did a good job of putting words. To the observations that normal people have, and really making that discussion accessible.

And again, it was something that I had felt but had never had never really thought about, never known how to talk about. And then once I was given some vocabulary to use it, I was took that to medical school, and it just influenced the way that I saw things and the way that I process things. And I was always looking at things through a lens of how can we improve our health outcomes and people's health and vitality and longevity simply by building things for people rather than for cars, and while I was in medical school, had the privilege of Chuck Marohn coming and doing a curbside chat.

I was in Peoria, Illinois, and he gave a talk in Peoria Heights, and I was lucky, and it was an event that did not conflict with my schedule, so I was able to go and really, saw it spelled out about kind of how incremental development and the traditional built environment, building pattern, building paradigm, really favored and coincided with the way that humans evolved. Like we evolved to walk. We evolved. We're extremely social creatures.

These are like physiologic facts, and it kind of blew my mind. Like, why, why do we spend so much time and money and effort going against our human nature for worse outcomes? And again, being someone who found that after living in Chicago, preferred to walk and preferred to bike. I was pretty focused on how can I how can I use my background and my experiences to try to help nudge people back towards our basic human tendencies in a way that supports us, a way that supports our nature, and I feel like there was a second part of that question that I did not answer.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  12:05

Well, no, it's great. And what it what it comes to mind is just it wasn't some modern luminary that made Chicago a place that you can have a choice as to whether or not you're going to use a vehicle or not. Instead, it was just this accumulation of like past building decisions and land use decisions that actually made a big difference, and I just think sometimes it's that like we have to learn from the past. I'm also really glad that our medical operating rooms look very modern.

Like that there's always an openness and an acceptance of like new methods, provided that they earn their keep and have that lasting value. And whenever we talk about like the necessity of public health being directly connected to good streets and people being able to walk in their neighborhood or people being able to overcome loneliness by actually being connected in sort of casual ways with people, there's often this sense of like, well, yeah, that makes sense.

But do you have any tips or suggestions for people that maybe aren't medical professionals as you are, but want to be able to sort of bring in that lens and find that it sometimes is just either ignored or people are like, oh yeah that's nice, but then they always go to this like, but reality requires us to do something different. You're like, does it? Yeah, what's something that's worked for you, or that is in the process of hopefully working?

Matt Schaeffer  13:24

Yeah, well, it's funny you mention that because even within medicine, where you think people are going to be the most sensitive to this to this messaging and most receptive to it, there's there's there's always going to be people who are on board 100% right from the start, and there's always going to be detractors, and even in the field of work that we do, inevitably I get the question of like, okay, but what about the person who's drunk or high and steps out into the street in front of a car? And I don't think I've formulated a perfect rebuttal to that, but one rebuttal I have is people have been getting drunk and high since humans have evolved, but it's the last 100 years that people died on their way home from doing it.

So which one is the bigger issue, and how can we again how can we address things to try to help people and meet them where they are? But then on the other side of things, I think if anything, I my story has shown that you don't have to abandon what you're already doing to incorporate this message, and really just figuring out how those how those threads inter interconnect and intertwine, and I found a way to be like, hey, this is something that I'm passionate about, and I spend a lot of time thinking about.

And I also really, really enjoy taking care of people, and I really enjoy the trauma response and being able to acutely help someone in their worst hour. So how can I weave those together so that I really enjoy my work? People not in the medical field, I think, have that same opportunity. whether you work in accounting or as a teacher or things like that, you can be involved in your community and you can bring your strengths to either the Strong Towns conversation or the built environment, or urbanist conversation, or the other way around.

If you have a strong background in that, do have community members and neighbors who are doing other things who might be really receptive to that, and you can reach out. I so many of my so many of my connections have just come from a cold email and saying, "Hey, I heard your talk, or I have been exposed to your work, and I'm really interested in that, and I think that we could work together, or I think I could learn from you, or I have something to offer." People are really receptive, and they people generally just want to help and want to be able to work with in collaboration with others to make the world a little bit better than they found it.

So I think just keeping in mind that you don't have to be perfect. You don't have to have a ton of free time. you don't have to have everything set up for you to help out, but you probably can bring something with what skills, what knowledge, what time you have to help keep moving the conversation forward and to just make your home, your street, your neighborhood a little bit better.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  16:38

Yeah, Matt, I bet people today really needed this, so thank you. It reminds me that it's good to be impatient, and it's just as important to be kind. And I think that combination can actually begin to really, drive change and help us in so many different ways. And as I think about it, what is it that gives you hope as you continue to carry on this work?

Matt Schaeffer  16:59

Yeah, lots of things to be hopeful for, and to focus on what I'm doing now at WashU and in St. Louis is that St. Louis is just a fascinating place that combines many big city amenities with a little bit of a smaller city nowadays. But really, I think is one of those hidden gems with actually a lot of that remnant missing middle housing. The city is currently undergoing a zoning code update. They're really working on building out a greenway infrastructure that is focused on connecting places where people actually want to go.

So it is focused on connecting the major parks and the major places of work, as well as the arch and the riverfront, and we have Forest Park, which people from St. Louis know is bigger than Central Park and was designed by the same person. So I think really St. Louis and the team I work with at WashU are really doing a good job of kind of capturing the moment and doing things that are going to help people rather than just look like a big flashy project.

So, and I know St. Louis isn't alone, and there are a lot of places doing that. So, that's what gives me encouragement that this is starting to catch on, and we're seeing it in, we're seeing it in laypeople circles, in academic circles, in government circles. People are finding that there's a lot of commonality and a lot of shared interest, and that this is something that we can do to help each other and to bring each other closer.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  18:40

Oh man, that's that's awesome! I love it, and I'm really excited for the folks in Pensacola that are going to be able to catch your session live, and hopefully we get a recording of it because just it's gripping and it's such an important part. Thank you for being part of that critical part of our care response to people in need. But then I really appreciate also the insights that flow from you of like here's how we broaden that discussion, bring more people in.

Not everyone has to be at the operating table, but many more people need to be at the table as we figure out all right what do we want our place to really be. And picking up from Chuck what he said, if you love your place, it will love you back. Any city, any town, any community. If you love your place, it will love you back. You'll find all of these ways in which you realize, wow, I'm privileged to be able to call this home, and I've also got a deep sense of obligation here.

And so, Matt, it's so good to have you on Bottom Up Shorts. Thanks for coming on today.

Matt Schaeffer  19:34

Thank you so much for having me. This was a great discussion. I loved it.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  19:38

Great to do it, and really appreciate it. And again, if you want to connect with Matt, definitely look for some of his talks on YouTube and other places. And we'll share some links in the show notes. Really appreciate you participating in Bottom Up Shorts today as an audience member. I hope you take heart too as hearing Matt talk about the importance of finding your path in your community. And then advocating together for safety, for better life outcomes.

Together, we can certainly make this happen. So, with that, take care and take care of your places. This episode was produced by Strong Towns, a nonprofit movement for building financially resilient communities. If what you heard today matters to you. Deepen your connection by becoming a Strong Towns member at strongtowns.org/membership.

‍

Additional Show Notes: