Bloomberg is betting that housing reforms in Austin, Atlanta, and San Diego can work elsewhere, but how much of that success can actually be replicated? Host Carlee Alm-LaBar speaks with Atlanta architect Eric Kronberg of Kronberg Urbanists and Architects and Haylee Rea of the Strong Towns San Diego Local Conversation about Vox's How Housing Victories in San Diego, Austin, and Atlanta Could Spread Nationwide. Austin loosened zoning restrictions, San Diego accelerated housing approvals, and Atlanta created a strike force to advance development. Each offers something worth studying, though their uneven results leave plenty of room to question what has worked and which obstacles these celebrated reforms have yet to address.
Cities across the country are dealing with many of the same housing problems, but they often tackle them one place at a time. Bloomberg Philanthropies is testing a different approach by taking reforms that have already shown results in San Diego, Austin, and Atlanta, and helping other cities adapt them instead of starting from scratch. Rachel Cohen Booth writes about that effort in an October 13th Vox article called "How Housing Victories in San Diego, Austin, and Atlanta Could Spread Nationwide." San Diego sped up permitting for affordable housing. Austin made it easier to add smaller scale housing, and Atlanta created a housing strike force to move projects through multiple public agencies.
Bloomberg is now funding other cities to try versions of those approaches, That leaves us with our question for today, the question many working in housing are actively wrestling with every day: When a housing reform works in one city, what does it take to make it work somewhere else? Welcome to Upzoned, a podcast from Strong Towns, where we look beyond the headline and at the systems, trade-offs, and assumptions shaping our cities and towns. My name is Carlee Alm-LaBar, I'm the chief of staff here at Strong Towns. I've got two great guests with me today.
First, joining us from Atlanta is Eric Kronberg, founder and principal at Kronberg Urbanists and Architects. His work brings together architecture, urban design, development, and policy, with a particular focus on zoning the rules that shape what can actually get built. Eric is a standard bearer in the housing space, and we're thrilled to welcome him. Thanks for joining us, Eric.
Thank you for having me. Excited to be here.
And from San Diego, one of the other cities, we have Haylee Rea, who serves on San Diego's mobility board and helped found the Strong Towns local conversation there. Strong Towns San Diego. Haylee was also part of last year's Strong Towns cohort, where advocates from around the country spent eight months digging into Strong Towns ideas the challenges they were working through in their own communities. Haylee, welcome! Thanks for being here.
So excited to be here! Thank you.
All right, I'm going to start with you, Eric. What did you think when you read the article?
Oh man! Well, I was really excited to hear what Austin was doing and loved to learn about San Diego. Then I always love a chance to talk about what we're seeing in Atlanta. It's important when we talk about our Strike Force, we say "pew" is the name for it because you know Star Wars and Arnold, and Atlanta gets a lot of stuff right, we do a really great job messaging these really big ideas, then execution or the other parts really tend to be subpar.
So I'm happy to go deep in strike force, the big idea for the mayor and his former housing staff was to look at all the municipal-controlled property in the city of Atlanta, that's not just owned by the city, schools, the development authority, the county. They mapped all that, they realize there's a lot of underutilized assets. That's a really important thing to do. Recommend every city does that, then they decided to also create a strike force to help prioritize moving these big projects or bigger projects through the system, which I'll have a lot of less glowing things to say about. But that's a high-level intro.
Absolutely. How about you, Haylee? San Diego was getting some plaudits in the article, and looking to maybe be replicated. What are your thoughts as someone who lives there?
I really enjoyed the article. I like how it drew connections between three different large cities who are all tackling the same problem in different ways. I think it shows that there's not one solution, that we can each take what we have in our cities, the you know the people power the institutional knowledge, we can come to the same problem, we can create different solutions. Then I like how the article put those next to each other, because I think in the United States we can learn so much if we look city to city and see where other people have had wins and how we can adopt the lessons from other cities, so we can start somewhere then create an incremental approach, as we learn in the Strong Towns method, to tackle this problem of housing the housing shortages and how expensive it is from as many sides as possible. So I really enjoyed learning about Austin and Atlantas well.
Yeah, I think from a you know from a Strong Towns perspective, when we talk about housing, we often talk about you know we've got to look at the regulations, look at who's going to build them. Look at the financing, that kind of these problems are so complex and cannot be simply addressed. So maybe Eric, I'll do the first substantive question. You talked about or you hinted at, I guess, already the strike force having its limitations, I wonder if there's a if there's kind of an immediate flag in the idea that you know housing has to be addressed from multiple angles, then you know are is there a risk in the in this model that's described in the article of making communities think that there's potentially just one solution that they need to work through.
So for context, I'm going to go really high level. One of the positives is our mayor. One of his benchmark goals is that he wants to have 20,000 units of affordable housing delivered over his two terms, it's admirable goal. My pushback is that when you look at the data, the need in Atlanta is probably somewhere around 30 to 40,000 units of housing, depending how you count it. So I feel like he, politicians want to set a goal that feels worthy but is achievable, as opposed to potentially a goal that is actually true and necessary, because the higher you set the goal, obviously the more prone to failure.
But the more you realize you have to do to accomplish it. And our mayor was trying to figure out how to do things without touching our zoning ordinance. Like that was a specific mandate he gave his staff. Like basically, what can we do with low income housing tax credits? Do X, Y, Z? We don't want touch zoning, which you know is a core barrier, so they leverage the city-owned land as a way to try to do more housing. I think as like leveraging city-owned land is amazing; it's a great idea, should be done.
But they've really kind of put this as the one thing for the past the first term. We're in our second term right now, the other challenge is that the strike force is really supposed to help prioritize permit review for projects coming through the system by giving you access to kind of a coordinated, consolidated review with like department heads and leaders. The challenge we face in Atlanta is our departments are pretty stratified within departments, so even if you have somebody talking to the head of a department, like you're not talking to the person reviewing your plans, right?
You're not hearing the specific roadblocks as to why they're taking two months to review your plans, and like what the holdup is. So, it's not really meaningfully decreasing the time through the system per se. All it is doing is prioritizing regular time to these projects. So, if you're not in a strike force or affordable housing track, good luck getting a permit. So, we only do affordable housing projects in Atlanta because if we're not at the affordable housing track, we're not going to get permits for our clients. It's a waste of everybody's time. So, that's an interesting trade-off you can make for a place.
But they didn't really invest in staff and trying to push things through or build capacity to move things along or look at fixing the zoning. The zoning is ongoing, so you could say, well, that's a debatable thing as to what they're doing with that. But it's really, really hard. One of my favorite anecdotes is in the transportation department. Every building permit probably has, or most building permits probably have a curb cut, right? Some car is going to come onto the site, come off the site. We got one reviewer for the city of Atlanta that does all those.
Yeah, there's a handful of other people in the transportation department that look at streetlights and stuff like that. But Juan is an amazing human being, we love Juan. Bless his heart. So glad he's there. I wish the city would get him some other people to work with him, right? Like filling vacant positions and staffing up would be critical to if you want to fix the process.
Eric, there was so much there that I'm not even sure which question to ask, so maybe I'm actually gonna go to Haylee first, then come back to you. Haylee, the article references San Diego's streamlined permitting. Have you noticed, as a local conversation leader whose organization champions housing, changes on the ground?
Yes, we have. We can see it both in the built environment. We do a lot of walks through the city, trying to show people what housing growth looks like and how it can match the neighborhood. So there definitely is an increased presence, the streamlining of the permitting processes for all of these projects is noticeable, it is very quick, so we are very thankful for that because it has stabilized rent increases. If you know connect it to inflation, so we have that. It's still a very high cost of living city, so it may not necessarily look like that when you just look at the whole numbers.
It's still not going to be any sort of rents that you're going to you know chuckle at and be like, oh, that's going to be great. But we are making a lot of progress. I will say, in a similar vein, though, that streamlining is only happening for certain types of projects. So, one of my co-executive leads, his wife runs one of the oldest redevelopment companies in San Diego. It's very small scale, very incremental, they still have maybe a nine-month-ish turnaround time for their permits, so we are seeing a lot of success in a certain subset that is definitely helping, especially with our dual problems of housing price and homelessness in San Diego.
So we are seeing a lot of gains, but that is being handed out not across the board and not in the way that we would want to see to fully address the problem from all the different tools and avenues that we have available. So I view it as a good first step. I think where a lot of the projects are going up. They are in usually high transit demand areas, it is serving a very real need. I think it sets the floor rather than the ceiling.
Eric, the article references, you referenced, the lack of staff capacity, you know the article was highlighting Bloomberg Philanthropies coming in and saying, "Hey, Austin, Atlanta, San Diego, these places are doing something right. We're going to go fund other communities to replicate these wins." it sounds like some of those communities are going to get staff capacity that goes along with you know kind of these prioritization and these policy changes. So you know maybe if you had a magic wand, Eric, what would be staffing that you would prioritize in Atlanta? Then you know I know you do a lot of development outside of Atlanta.
What are things that you've seen in other communities where you know you could say like these? This is something that all communities need versus like this is something that could really help Atlanta's permitting processes to speed up and get us more housing.
Yeah, so I think a great way to think about it is there's a capacity need of humans to review plans and go through the building process relative to the complexity of the ordinances you put in place, right? So if and this is a Goldilocks conversation of like how complex of an ordinance? What are you trying to regulate? How much? I am not a wild west has turned all loose kind of guy. I'm not for the system we have now. For reference, our current zoning ordinance is antiquated. It's been periodically updated here there. But we have most districts that you would try to get a permit in to build something.
Usually, you'll have a single district that is about 20 to 30 pages, maybe some overlay components with a lot of written form-based requirements. Porches, stoops, streetscapes. But it's so complicated that it's hard to comply with. And all these districts require you to get a permit before you can go get a permit, right? Permit for a permit is so you have to go through a whole full zoning review to be allowed to go to all the other departments. The that can take you know 60 to 90, 120 days or more, depending on how complex your project is.
The fun thing is the moment you get it's called a special administrative permit, or SAP. In case I start throwing acronyms around, the moment you get your SAP you go to the next stage. Sometimes it's site for the project. Other times it's the buildings. The first thing they do is check everything against your SAP again to check the zoning all over again a second time. So you have like two zoning reviews back to back. You need a lot of staff to do that. When you know probably I don't know the percentage, but the if it's a historic district, it's a special public interest district, it's a quality of life district.
All our typical districts that you're going to build in, other than a handful of single-family districts, have to get that SAP permit. So if you think about, is it maybe two-thirds ish of not by land area, but of permits coming through the system? It's a major portion of permits all require this review. That's a lot of staff, right? Now, what's even may sound counterintuitive and crazy is our proposed zoning 2.0, which is very much being fought out right now, is way more complex than our current zoning. And to help us out, they said they're going to get rid of this SAP process.
Well. Then you wouldn't know if you have compliance with the zoning till the very last stage of your building permit. After you spend all the money and all the engineering, all the architecture, and everything else to find out how the city feels about it from a zoning compliance standpoint for a code even more complex than our current one. So I tell people the only thing worse in our SAP process is not having one if you have a really complex zoning ordinance. So when we talk about staff and staff levels, it's really a question of relative to what are you trying to administer and enforce.
We have a very robust stormwater ordinance, which takes a fair amount of review. We've got a very robust tree protection ordinance and a very challenging zoning ordinance, they don't play well together at all, right? So all these departments have a lot of staffing needs. I will say historically, of all that, the building department, which is separate or I mean related, but like the building review is separate from those. That's relatively straightforward, right? Like it's building code, it's you know engineering plumbing code, more black and white, but zoning storm and site and trees, it's it's hard.
So as you're trying to figure out the staffing, you should think about the ordinances. And nobody thinks about cost, not just cost that the ordinances place on the buildings, but if you want to have 1,000-page zoning ordinance. It's really like 981. I'm hyperbolic here in terms of the proposed length of our zoning. You're going to need a lot of people. Like I have joked that our new proposed zoning ordinance is like you know it's a long-term planner employment plan, right? Because there's no way the city can exist without an insane number of planners because it's so complicated. Like there are other ways to calibrate staff level and regulatory requirements.
Yeah, there are two things I want to. One thing I want to emphasize, then I want to circle back to a question is that idea that you know I think is very true that as the complexity of what you're trying to regulate increases, you are as a community necessarily increasing the capacity it's going to take for your people to review that, so you know that can be something for folks to consider as they're implementing new policies. What do I have on the other side of this to really be able to do this, or is this just going to make things harder in my community?
What have you seen? Because your firm does a lot of work outside of Atlanta, I'm sure many of the things that you just shared are true outside of Atlanta. But what's what's different? Where have you seen communities thrive or do things well from a regulatory and administrative perspective,
So it's a little bit unfair. But we're getting we have the chance to work with a lot of cities, that are like maybe 20 to 70,000 people, so you just have less hierarchy, right? And less levels of staff in your department. So maybe there's a department head and like a handful of staff, and as opposed to many, so you're able to make sure you get buy-in on the high-level vision, right? That this is the project,. As elected officials and civic leaders, like we all think this is a great pilot. We want to see this done, so staff has been told to find a way to get to yes, right?
Like let's figure out how to have a good project. But when there's a bias towards yes, it's very different than you're just a staffer with without a dog in the fight. You like Atlanta, like the mayor has a mission. That mission doesn't seem to filter down effectively to staff just trying to do their jobs. But also another component of this is, I think this is sort of in defense of some arborists. Like the ordinance doesn't give them discretion, right? So if you have no discretionary powers in your ordinance, like it's really hard to get to yes because it's like these are the rules, these are the laws, you got to follow them.
It was just as a story to share the absurdity of the arborist. We had a huge spat with city council and our arborist. They were trying to do a city-funded project to improve stormwater runoff and sewer capture in a disinvested neighborhood in a creek bed. So, city project, city land, trying to get this done. The arborist wouldn't let them cut down a couple trees, the city council lost their mind. My expectation is he had no mechanism to say yes. City council elected to pass a law that said they were exempt from the tree ordinance for the sake of this project.
Like that was their solution to the problem. And like we don't get that. Like that is not an option when you're doing affordable housing for like nonprofits in the private sector. We don't get to raise her hand say, like the mayor said, this is important. We want to opt out of this rule, right? So you're just stuck. So it's like staffing rules, regular. It's like, do you want to be biased to yes? It's sort of like it's less about the staff levels. It's more is there full directional buy-in with what a city or town is trying to do?
And can you work together to get there? And can you get the you know whether it's the site guy, the building guy, the zoning? If there's only two or three people, can you all just can we all have a call and talk it out and find a way? Like that, like the strike force is allegedly supposed to do that in Atlanta, but it's more like upper level folks from departments who have zero working knowledge of the ordinances, right? Like it's a political position, not a technical position, so they have no knowledge of like section blah of the tree ordinance or this part of the zoning ordinance. They just know the project before and don't understand why they're on their fifth meeting and nothing's happened.
Right? Yeah, yeah, I think that you know in communities, this article highlights you know bigger cities like Austin, Atlanta, San Diego, the reality is that to get change all the way down in a city like that is it can be really challenging because you know those governments are large, Eric. The story that you told about the arborist reminded me. I worked in City Hall for about eight years, and in the planning office.
I used to tell developers who would come to me, like, "I'll work to change the law with you, but I'm not going to break the law for you." Right, that's kind of the situation that you the arborists find themselves in, but then in a place like Atlanta, changing that law is harder than communities like you said of 20,000, 70,000, et cetera, that have more direct access to the mayor. It's quite challenging. I think that's why we see investment in larger cities, because I think the philanthropy realizes, these places need additional investment to make progress.
I'm curious, and maybe Eric, you can take this first, but I'd be curious, Haylee, if you have anything you want to chime in. Also, the when you're working in a community when you're thinking about the communities you guys live in, how do you how do you diagnose what's really blocking housing? Because when we have conversations, there's it feels like there's a million factors, it's it's like how do you, as a professional, Eric, diagnose it, then maybe Haylee, you as a community leader, how do you focus on what you advocate on?
I'll start with let's start at the end, right? What are the results? I want to start because I want to pull Austin back into the conversation from the article. Pew Charitable Trust did some amazing analysis of housing and rent declines in Austin the big supply boost they've had over the past like seven or eight years, so part of what Bloomberg was highlighting the article was like a lot of the small lot reform, small lot splits, a range of things that Austin's done, along with other zoning reform, parking reduction reform. Like Austin's throwing a lot of stuff at the wall, they're having measurable results.
And one of the ones that I really love to tease out is very much in the pro supply side of things, which is not the only thing to worry about. But Austin's seen a meaningful decline in their Class C apartments rents, right? Their lowest Class apartments. They're not building any more of those, but the rent and population pressure on those apartments have lifted. So landlords have got to lower the rents to keep people in them. Like that's a net benefit of all the things, right? So very pro supply in that regard, with tangible evidence to show much that's helped.
So like that's a great thing. The flip side for Atlanta, we there's a great measure called the Gini coefficient where it measures the incomes of the bottom 20% of your population versus the incomes of the top 5%. And how unequal are those? Right, those amounts. Like if the top 5% have all the money the bottom have nothing, that's a one. If the bottom 20% have everything the top 5% have nothing. That's a zero. We that's a great metric to look at just income, not wealth, but income. Atlanta's been the worst major city in that regard for the past decade.
There's been some great competition and metrics looking at between Atlanta, Charlotte, then Research Triangle, Raleigh-Durham, and Charlotte and Raleigh-Durham taken meaningful reforms over the past five years. All kinds of ways: land use, transportation, otherwise, they're getting meaningfully less unequal. Atlanta has not. Atlanta is doing great performative work to deliver attainable housing on city-owned land, but that is a drop in a bucket compared to the need, and particularly compared to the need to the metro, which we're just a piece of. So, we're not getting the results. And Austin provides a good example of you kind of got to throw it all at the wall, right?
And try a lot of things, right? It is transportation policy and transportation investment. Again, the park. Reform small lot splits legalizing housing right. I was I was in um Richmond earlier this week, I think one of the questions I came away with for them is as they're trying to do their own zoning rewrite. I was like, really, how much housing should you be allowed to ban in your city? What's the right level of that? You look at California, the state has said you have to allow a certain amount of housing. You can't ban anything below a duplex, more or less, with SB 9.
You know some of these other components. Washington State, Oregon said very similar things. Montana said you have to allow four units of housing per lot if you've got utilities. Like that's the least amount of housing you can ban. Atlanta, we're still primarily a single-family city. It's a highly correlated outcome to really bad housing policy and being the most unequal city in America.
Yeah, Haylee Eric referenced transportation. I know that's one of the things that you work on, I believe there's been some progress in San Diego, on that front, I'd love for you to share kind of what the local conversations been involved in there related to housing and transportation.
Yes, of course. And just to start tying into some things that Eric said that popped into my mind when I think about San Diego is also the how do we make sure the housing is being built where it should be in San Diego and not overly concentrated in one areand non-existent in another? Because then that will just perpetuate further inequalities. Whether that is looking at the tax revenue that comes off of the land or the increase to the transit ridership that is being supplied, because in San Diego we have districts that touch the border with Mexico, then we have cities in between, then it becomes San Diego again.
So we have such a large range of land to deal with, we sometimes see that these development projects, whether they be the high number projects or the implementation of our ADU bonus program, are concentrated in some places more than others, and what that is doing and how that is changing the city. So we are seeing increases in density and livability in certain places more than others, if that continues for a couple years, how is that going to change the makeup of our city? And especially when we look at all of the beachfront neighborhoods and a lot of what they do, we have the California Coastal Commission that provides another overlay of what we can and cannot build.
We have a 30 foot height limit that we have to either get special allowance to go around, or we have to work underneath. So, how does that change our communities? But we are seeing a lot of success in building units and projects around our transit corridors, we actually just had the fifth birthday party for the Blue Line extension north that connected UCSD. So now you can go from UCSD all the way to Tijuana, you can walk across the border. So that is really the backbone of our transportation system. Then we also have the orange line the green line that are also seeing a lot of great projects come online as we kind of shift.
We talk a lot about in San Diego how we are just you know we are very Southern Californiand we are very chill. A lot of people have this mentality that you know we aren't a big city, but we are. We are the eighth largest city in the country, so we have to think about what that means and what that means for people who already live here and people who want to move here, and what that life will be like. People are not going to stop moving here. We have a lot of different industries that pull people in, so we think about that adds another layer when people want to change houses or they want to move here.
What does that life look like for them? If it is a family, how many cars are they bringing? We do a lot of work at Strong Towns, raising this idea that you can bring your car to San Diego that is still very valid, but there are trips that you don't need a car for anymore, and our development is reflecting that now with the number of parking spaces that can be allowed or not allowed for all of these new projects, so it's it's a slow change, I think our place in it is doing a lot of the outreach the education and showing people how you can go to Pacific Beach or North Park or downtown, all of these places that do have good transit access and say like you can have that San Diego lifestyle that you may not have.
Envisioned before that is still accessible, even with these new type of housing units, using the public service that is public transportation that you know has a foundation. And as more people use it, we learn what it is, we can move into this idea of the San Diegan who takes transit? Who lives not in a single-family home, but is still culturally part of this identity, and has the beach, and has the downtown, and has the small-town feel still. So I think it's a lot of changes, they are coming very quick. I think the executive order from the mayor was very successful, as well as the ADU bonus program, so there's a lot going on.
But within the Strong Towns community, the people that we talk to, they're feeling very positive about it. They're always happy to learn. We try to make our events very engaging and fun about what it can look like and bringing everybody's viewpoint in, so we can build the future together.
That's great. You talked about being, a San Diegan. I hope I got that pronunciation correctly, Eric. You've talked about how Austin kind of threw spaghetti on the wall for results. I'm curious, like, then you referenced Atlanta's historic kind of single-family housing. I'm gonna call it a culture, even. I'm curious how much Eric you think that the local market determines what's possible, determines the reforms that work, and ultimately, when we think about this program in terms of replicability, and what I think the article says, Bloomberg's trying to do is give ideas that many other cities can use. What would maybe be some of your cautions about, translating lessons, or maybe your enthusiasm about translating lessons. How would you encourage people to think about that?
So I think from a land use perspective, like just for reference, there's a great group, the Emergency National Emergency Housing Task Force, right? They've put out a lot of great best practices for what should happen, and our mayor is a co-chair. I think it's the mayor of Salt Lake or the governor from Utah. Get one of those two is the other co-chair, they've got these amazing recommendations of land use policy reforms that need to get done. Allowing more housing by transit. Up to four to six units per every lot in the city.
It's this laundry list of great policy, so we've got a mayor that's the co-chair of this national organization putting out amazing policy, it sure is amazing that our draft zoning 2.0 had none of that in it, right? So there's an intentionality here. There's an implementation challenge, right? There's a lot of things that are hard. And Haylee, one question I wanted to ask you to go back to San Diego to come to this is for all your TODs transit-oriented development work. How much of that was I know didn't the state pass some laws that enabled that right, or how much did San Diego do ahead of or beyond the state enabling legislation to allow TODs as of right?
We've done a bit. There was last year we had SB 79, which was another transit-oriented development bill that passed that were very thankful for. And some other local advocacy groups went to our city council to present their own map because it differed from the city's, and were able to get more projects put onto that, but even preceding that in San Diego, we did not get rid of our parking requirements, but we did in these transit zone overlays, which, if you look at the map, covers a decent amount of the city depending on the frequency of the transit service.
Functionally, I would say a majority of the city falls underneath those, that clears a lot of the hurdles, be it for density or required parking. So were able to have that impetus before SB 79 went into effect, and beyond that, the city it was in full commitment to reaching our goals that were set by the state. I think of all of the cities in California, San Diego city is most on track to reaching our housing goals. I know that was one of the mayor's chief priorities was to do housing, so whatever it took to get that going has been happening.
So now it's been you know three four years, we're starting to see the outcomes of what that's been happening. So every time we get a new transit-oriented development ordinance or state law that kind of just piles on top. We also have something called complete communities because we've divided San Diego into 52 separate communities, then each one has a community plan. It is also a priority of the city that we are going through some of these plans that are 15, 20, 25 years old, we're reassessing them. That's something that we do at the mobility board.
We look at it. The city planners come to us with what they think the new density should be or what units should be allowed. We give our input. Then they take that to the next committee, so we're slowly, piece by piece, tying that together, mostly around our core, our three trolley lines, then we have three rapid buses, and seeing what we can do to take the bright spots that we already have and focus a lot there while not forgetting the other places where it is applicable that are not in fire zones, not in flood zones, and making sure we take in elements of underserved neighborhoods and things like that.
So, for as much as I would say what we can do, we always talk about how LA went all in on transit, and San Diego went all in on housing, and now we're learning from each other as well. In my opinion, we've struck a good balance. I always have you know comments that I would say that I'd want things to go faster, but we're in the middle of I would say a good shift towards what we'd like to see.
So I asked all that because we have no state mandates in Georgia, right? Right. There's nothing. There's no pressure from the state, right? So imagine if you didn't have state level housing targets, you had to hit state level mandates to legalize housing, state level mandates to legalize transit-oriented development. Imagine like the point of this is, I think fundamentally, just the way with district systems and local council people, then the mayor, it's almost impossible to be brave, right? Or it's so hard to do the right thing because the odds or fear of getting punished and voted out by so many folks is real, even if you're a big housing advocate.
So it's hard to do the right thing, I think that's structural. So we spend a lot of time thinking about what is the right level of reform at the state level versus local, right? What's which is like how much housing should you be allowed to ban as a city? That should be a state level question, right? Like it is not being asked in Georgia, right? Almost every other state in the southeast, has passed some meaningful level of housing policy. It's Georgiand South Carolinare the only two that haven't, right? I think even Mississippi's done something.
So, like when Mississippi's done it in the south, like something, right? So, I've been hearing rumblings that South Carolina is going to do some stuff, there's nobody knows what Georgia's going to do next, right? So, the regulations, the approaches, there is a there is a role for the state to play. California is, as a state, has been very proactive in the space for longer than I think every other state in the nation. You guys have seen results. It spread from Washington, Oregon, even Montana. These state level reforms matter, we're not going to get there.
I don't know that humans are able to get there on our own, or it has to get so bad. Like, like we're not LA homelessness. I'm not trying to compare us to that, but homelessness is a massive challenge in Atlanta because we have no housing, right? It's a direct connection. You have no housing, affordable or otherwise, you're going to have a homelessness crisis. And check a box. We do. We'll see what our council does. They're allegedly we're working on trying to get the zoning ordinance fixed to a better place. I believe the people working on fixing it will get us an ordinance that would work. Whether or not that gets approved is a very, very different question.
I like how you put that because before we had SB 79. We had a different bill that the name and number is escaping me right now. But that one was essentially an opt in, we saw no cities opt in. So I know we talk a lot in Strong Towns about state preemption and what role that plays when we are a bottom-up group, when that's what we're trying to, talk to people and get them to have input. I agree.
At the end of the day, we do need housing, it did give it did open a lot of doors for the types of housing that we need in the places that we need it, so everyone was always like, "Oh, you should let the cities decide this." It's like, well, they did, and most did not participate. And even with SB 79 and our other state housing mandates and goals that we have to reach, we are seeing some cities in California, find ways to navigate that, to avoid that, I think that goes back to what I said earlier.
Even within the city of San Diego, how do we make sure the housing that we build, covers all the different communities that we have, because people want to live in certain places, and certain places I don't think should just be able to opt out completely and fossilize themselves into the single-family housing model, so we see an interesting tension and back and forth between the state the city, and some of our city council members are now the ones up at the state making those housing policies.
So, when we think about what do we want as San Diego and what do we want as California, and how do we provide homes for all of the people that already live here, you try to do what we can to ameliorate this cost of living crisis that we're in, and tackle our homelessness crisis as well. It's going to take so many different avenues. So at the end of the day, I think I am thankful for a lot of the state bills and ordinances that have passed.
We're going to have to do a whole separate episode on state preemption and talking about that, you know I think because there's there's so much there. I guess as we kind of get to the end, I'm curious for each of you to have like a last word. What were your takeaways, or what are things that Eric you wish we would have talked about that. Cities should be thinking of when it comes to, building housing in their community and making it possible, making it legal, getting it financed, getting it done.
Yeah. So fundamentally, I'll try not to go too long on this, but different kinds of housing have very different costs based on square footage. What I mean by that is anything built under the residential code, single family, duplex, or townhome is going to be way more cost effective on a square foot basis than large commercial buildings out of steel and concrete, towers, even five story apartment buildings. It just, it just, it's that, so when we talk about trying to solve our problems with you know a bunch of big buildings on a corridor, four stories, 20 stories, whatever, like those are our most expensive building types, right?
That is the hardest way to solve an affordability crisis, right? The ways that if you want to hit more directly are allowing smaller, more straightforward buildings to be built, duplexes or double duplexes on a lot, or otherwise. I just want to reiterate Austin's small lot splits that really enable that, right, as a big deal because you're allowing smaller housing under a simpler building code that has a chance to be more attainable. Now, land cost isn't split as much, so you want to take that one lot and let four to six units of housing be built on that.
That's what Washington State said. Seattle and Tacoma have to do. You're a major city near transit. You have to allow six fee-simple homes on a lot if the builder wants to do it. Full stop. That's the kind of policy that really has an impact because you're going to be more straight down the middle for attainability, right? If you can overlay that with those neighborhoods near transit, transit adjacent, maybe not at the stop, right where it should be a bigger building because land is really valuable. But it's all that fabric around that we need to think about.
So I want to give Austin a shout out for that being one of the many things they've done that our mayor is highly recommending that every city in America do through the National Emergency Housing Task Force, I sure hope we get to do it in Atlanta too because that would be amazing.
I love it, you know we say sometimes at Strong Towns incremental housing everywhere, I think that was, you express that just making that possible in more and more and more places. Haylee, last word before we go to the Downzone.
Yeah, I think mine is something similar that I wanted to explicitly touch on. That I like Austin's model, I think all roads lead back to discussing zoning reform, especially in Californias we operate under Prop 13, we are constricted in the amount of revenue that can come from different lots and developments. And San Diego historically had so many different housing types. My favorite is the cottage court that are functionally illegal now, that's you know it can be four to 12 units depending on the lot size the arrangement, but I think if we took a good look at our zoning, whether it's a city level or a state level, there's a lot of opportunity there to keep that San Diego vibe, but not necessarily have those expensive mega projects that area. Was talking about, so I really congratulate Austin for doing that, I see it in our future, I am hopeful that we can get to that place.
That's great. We'll switch over to the Downzone, and where we get to ask you guys about what you've been reading, learning, watching, engaging with, and share it with the broader Strong Towns community, Eric. Because you've been a guest on Upzoned before, I'm going to ask you to go first. What do you want to share with our listeners?
So something I've been talking to clients about a lot in the past couple weeks is we've got many clients across the southeast that are focusing on first-time homebuyer infill housing developments, right? Often a little bit of state or philanthropic support, income limited, but very much small, cute housing for people making usually 60 to 80 to 120% of area median income, and nobody's selling houses, right? No houses are moving in Brunswick, Georgia, Dalton, Atlanta, Chattanooga. Like it's nothing's being sold, I've been really telling clients we've got to start thinking about lease to own or you know lease to rent something because interest rates are high, buyers are scared to death.
Then this morning, as I've been you know talking to clients, NPR had a story that says punch in the gut: home sales fall to their lowest in 16 years. That's this morning. I'm I'm moderately okay at math. We're in 2026. We're comparable to 2010, and for those of us that have been around in real estate and development in 2010, that was a really, really, really, really, really, really, really bad time to be in those industries, right? So we talk about zoning and policy. Maybe you shouldn't overreact to you know a major housing crisis with the worst housing since the Great Recession, or maybe you should, right? Maybe you really need to think about your policies relative to the worst housing market we've seen since the greatest housing crash since the Great Depression.
Yep. Yeah.
Like that's what we're seeing today.
Wow. Sobering. Thanks, Haylee. How about you?
I have two. Just because I think what I'm reading, I'm not sure if it counts for downzoned because last year I listened to the audiobook of The High Cost of Free Parking. A substantial tome. I loved it. And this year my challenge was to do The Power Broker. So I am about nine hours in to the audiobook, it is a challenge to listen to so much of it, but I think learning the foundations of all of this is really helping me. If we look at you know Robert Moses, it really goes into detail of everything that happened in New York in the 1920s.
So that's what I'm reading, or listening to. I think I recommend the audio book more than I would recommend reading it. But on a note of good news, this past Monday we had a six-hour, maybe seven-hour council meeting that I called into listen to all of it to vote, or the city council was voting on what's called Midway Rising, if it is made, which it passed, will be the largest housing development on a piece of public property in the state.
So it's taking a very large parcel of land, quite close to my house, that is currently a massive parking lot and a very aged sports event venue, they are going to build a new sports event venue and 4000 homes, 2000 of which are going to be rent restricted at different levels of area median income. In addition, the development company has agreed to do different sorts of upgrades to stormwater infrastructure, the fire station, transit lines, so while that is all wonderful and great, what really sparked joy in my heart was the you know three hours of public comment that went through, which did take a long time.
But I was very warmed that so many people from advocacy agencies to people in different organizations and unions, and different community leaders, and just general members of the public calling in. I think it's something that we can't understate the power of raising our voice with our electeds at any level that we can. I know we talk a lot about the value of getting involved, so even though many of the public comments were not something that I agreed with, I nonetheless was happy that they were there because at the end of the day, I want the people in San Diego to be building San Diego or to be having input.
So I thought that was quite uplifting. That it passed unanimously. That so we will hopefully be able to have this wonderful new homes and arena sometime in the next decade.
Wonderful. Well, congratulations, I couldn't agree more on the civic involvement. There's you know even on those long city council nights, there's a good feeling around seeing that kind of your fellow citizens advocating. So congratulations. My Downzone is that this weekend I'll be participating in I'm in Lafayette, Louisiana, our annual 24-hour citizen project, which is a crowdfunding event for civic projects. So tonight we gather and help teams make their pitches better, then Saturday night we generally award four to five civic projects that get implemented. It's a this is the 10 year anniversary, it's it's been responsible for a lot of very, very impactful local civic projects in Lafayette, it's one of my favorite weekends of the year.
So, won't have very much time for reading this weekend, but we'll certainly, certainly be doing community work that I'm excited about. So, Eric and Haylee, thank you guys both so much for joining us on Upzoned today. I really enjoyed hearing your different perspectives, and appreciate your communities leading the way, and us being able to continue to learn from Atlantand San Diego what they're doing well and what they're doing maybe not as well. So thank you both for being here.
Thank you. I learned so much.
Yeah, absolutely. Thank you.
And to our listeners, please thank you for joining us. If you want to keep the conversation, please feel free to head on over to the Strong Towns Commons at commons.strongtowns.org. We'll be back next week with a new topic and a new group. And as always, take care of yourself and take care of your places.
This episode was produced by Strong Towns, a nonprofit movement for building financially resilient communities. If what you heard today matters to you, deepen your connection by becoming a Strong Towns member at strongtowns.org/membership tonight.