Back to Podcasts

The Strong Towns Podcast

Why More Housing Isn't the Same as Home

What happens when the financially sensible housing decision takes you further from the life you wanted to build? Journalist Jessica Barrett left expensive Vancouver for Calgary, where homeownership became possible but a sense of belonging remained elusive. Her book No Place Like Home follows that contradiction into a housing debate dominated by prices, supply, and arguments over density. She makes the case for asking residents how their neighborhoods should change before demanding they take sides, while challenging the assumption that the homes people need will emerge simply because developers build more units.

Chuck Marohn  0:09

Hey everybody! It is Chuck Marohn. Welcome back to the Strong Towns Podcast. I've had a book sitting on my desk for a long time, and I have a long list of books. People are very generous and send me things. This one caught my eye because it is about housing, but it's about housing in a way that I think is a little bit of a different perspective. We tend to get, I think, stuck often in the very rational, orderly, regulation type conversation about housing, and this one is going to be very, very different from that. I have Jessica Barrett. She's an award-winning journalist who has written a book called No Place Like Home: The Missing Key to Our Housing Crisis.

When she wrote this, she was in Calgary, but she's gone back and forth between Vancouver and Calgary, and now she's living in a little place outside of Vancouver called Burnaby. Jessica Barrett. Welcome to the Strong Towns Podcast.

Jessica Barrett  1:04

Ah, thanks for having me, Chuck. I'm I'm super excited for this one.

Chuck Marohn  1:07

My wife is a journalist, and I kind of know the profession a little bit. I feel like in every journalist somewhere, there's a great book. Talk to me a little bit about like why you thought this is the book I need to write, as opposed to like anything else you've been working on professionally. Like, what pushed you to have this book come out?

Jessica Barrett  1:29

If your wife is a journalist, then I'm sure you're familiar with the idea of journalistic objectivity, right? That we should be reporting on things at an arm's length distance and reporting just the facts, and so my career started in Vancouver, in British Columbia, sort of before I would say on the building momentum of the housing crisis that we are in today.

My career was sort of peaking at the time that the housing crisis was starting to peak in Vancouver as well, and I've been writing a lot about city governments and municipalities, and then I started writing columns from a millennial perspective about just trying to survive in the city, find an apartment, find a place where you could potentially raise a family, feeling connected in a neighborhood, having ways to participate in the democratic process as a renter and someone who was seen as not being a contributing part of a community, even though we were, and then what happened is I became the story in a way, in that I got priced out of Vancouver and I ended up moving to Calgary searching for more affordable housing, and I wrote an essay on the way out about why I was leaving, and that wasn't unique at the time.

It was something people were doing. It was a bit of a trend. It was something people were satirizing, and I, I really didn't think that it would make that big of a splash. But it ended up going viral, and then suddenly I was the poster child for the housing crisis, not just in Vancouver, but in Canada, and I was really at the center of it. And then I would say the discourse around housing was pretty cruel in Canada. this idea that like, oh, these young kids, these young millennials, they're just eating avocado toast and drinking lattes, and that's why they can't afford a house. Now,

Chuck Marohn  3:17

Let's let's say cruel by Canadian standards is a is a different thing, but I'm I'm with you. Yeah,

Jessica Barrett  3:24

That is true. That is true. I'll give you that one. And so there was a lot of the comment sections were really vicious. there was a lot of pushback to that, but then people started quietly reaching out on out to me privately with these like outpourings of feelings of grief and loss and estrangement, and isolation of just where do I go? Where do I go? Where do I find a home? How do I?

What decision should I make? Is it worth it to leave, or how do I stay? I realize that there's so much emotion tied up in housing and tied up in the housing crisis, and at the same time, I had left Vancouver to escape the housing crisis, and I moved into a city that was just got right into another one. And that's when I realized that this is a bit of a tsunami, like a sort of a swell that was going to absorb the whole country.

And so the book really came about, about me wanting to explore my own relationship to home, and having left a city in search of cheaper housing, and having found that housing, but not necessarily the sense of home that I was looking for. There's a lot of facts. I ended up going around the world looking at lots of different housing systems and the ways that people manage housing. But what it really is the separation of housing and home is two different things? housing is a structure, and when we talk about the housing crisis, a lot of it in North America starts from this idea of we can just get the buildings right. more missing middle, or more condo towers, or more duplexes, or whatever.

It is if we get the structure of the houses right, then homes will magically spring from them. And what I found is it's actually the opposite way. We need to look at home as a feeling that can be built through concrete actions like better relationships with our neighbors, more agency in making choices, a sense of place, a sense of belonging, and when we start that way, the types of housing that we need to create a real sense of home emerge from there.

So that's really the basis for the book.

Chuck Marohn  5:33

This is what I want to explore because I do feel like, as planners, as engineers, as people who work in trying to solve the housing crisis and deal with housing issues, I feel like we impose on humans a certain amount of rationality. In fact, I was having this conversation with my wife recently, and I said, I said, I feel like a lot of the frustrations are that we assume people will act rationally. As I read your book, I felt like one part, like you were saying, "Hey, I'm going to make a rational decision in my life," and it didn't end up the way you wanted it to.

I felt like other times you describe in the book ways you or others would make what I think an outside observer would say would be an irrational decision, and actually ended up kind of in a better place. I wonder how much of our sense of the housing crisis or housing itself comes from the fact that the financially rational choice and the human rational choice are often like two very different things.

Jessica Barrett  6:43

I really love that you picked up on that. I think that's that's basically the central theme that I kept kind of dancing around in the book and really delving into in my own life first. And when I moved to Calgary, I was paying a fraction of what I paid in Vancouver for rent. I was able to buy a house. I was able to achieve all of those dreams of home ownership that is sold to us in North America as the foundation for any type of success as an adult. I would say, but it didn't feel like home. It just wasn't hitting me in my heart.

And really, what it came down to is my heart wasn't in it, and home is a feeling. It isn't a physical thing necessarily, and we are not rational beings fundamentally. I think the world would be a much better place if we could all kind of understand that although we are capable of making rational decisions, fundamentally we're all wounded inner children that need to feel safe and secure and loved before we can do anything of value, and I think nowhere is that more evident than when we're having the conversation about housing.

And so, when we look at things like a housing crisis, we have all of these professionals, architects, and planners, and developers, and politicians who are looking at this as a rational sort of math problem, right? If we create X amount of boxes for X amount of people, then they will all move in and be happy, healthy, contributing people in our society, and that's just not how we work. It's just not. we are fundamentally very emotional beings, and there is nothing. I don't think there are a few things that are more emotional than the topic of your home.

And so, when we talk about things like redeveloping neighborhoods or increasing density or however it is that we need to change people's homes, we have a tendency to dismiss people with terms like NIMBY or categorize them as YIMBYs or NIMBYs, or put them in certain camps. But when you're talking about a change to someone's home, whether or not the threat to them is real, like whether or not they're actually at risk of getting evicted or priced out or whatever, we are so deeply emotionally attached with our homes that we will perceive that as a threat, as a knee-jerk first reaction, no thanks. I hate it. I want my home to stay just like it is because I like it here, and I can't envision it changing.

And so, we need to start to acknowledge that's where most people are going to start, and what do and take steps to sort of alleviate those fears and that knee-jerk emotional response, and make room for it in our public discourse before we can get to a rational decision about okay, but the reality is we have a housing crisis and we need X amount more houses in this price range by X time. How are we going to do that together as a community?

Chuck Marohn  9:36

I feel like what you just said is really dangerous in some housing policy circles where it really is about how do we get the biggest project, the most built? gentrification is like a sad, casualty of what we do. I struggle with this because I feel like the rational part of me looks at like a zoning code and says, "All right, I can tweak this and make this different." And make this better, and have it work out.

And then, when you go out and meet people in the real world, and you experience it from their way, we might label them as NIMBYs, but their fears are not irrational. Their desires for the future are not irrational. Let me. I feel like a way to bridge this gap between the technical people who are going to hear this, who are part of our audience, but another part of our audience, I think, who will like very quickly identify with you. How do you think neighborhood change would look like if we started with existing residents not as obstacles to be overcome, or overwhelmed, or negated, or the problem, and instead said, "All right, your attachment to this place is important. It's actually the starting point.

What would what would it look like to start with that and then build on that in a way that got us more housing, got us more places. Got us a better system. What? How would you approach it from that angle?

Jessica Barrett  11:06

Yeah, this is a huge question for me as well in writing the book and researching it because I have I've sat in on so many city councils and public hearings and city meetings and I have a lot of respect for planners and people who build things. they're doing really hard work, and they are often the villains or classified as the villains in a lot of this work as well. it's not easy, and so I think this really comes down to the way that we do public input and public consultation is not only is it not effective; it is actually alienating people.

I think it comes down to we're asking the wrong questions. And so, for the book, I did interview, Calgary's director of planning, who'd written her PhD thesis on bringing empathy into the into the planning process, which I found fascinating. And so, there are people in the technical fields who are doing this work and realizing that there is a need for this change. And she made this point that we have a public hearing on a development proposal, and right away we ask people to stake a claim on one side of the issue: yes or no. Should we build a tower here? Yes or no.

For or against, do we want to increase density here? Yes or no, and instead, what we need to be asking people is how. we have X amount of people who don't have homes in this city. How are we going to work together as a community to solve this problem? And right away, it changes things, right? Because it's not just, how opens the door to a whole bunch of possibilities of questions that you can ask. It's not just how are we going to solve homelessness? How are we going to create more housing for people? It's also how can we keep the things you love in your community, the things that make you feel at home here.

How can we create the opportunity for you to downsize in your neighborhood, in your community, and stay in your home, change up your housing potentially, but stay in your home for your entire life? and then you start to have a completely different conversation. It's much more involved upfront, and it starts with a lot earlier of a contact point, I think, between people who work at cities and municipalities and people who are in communities. I saw a lot of really good examples of how to do that. Vienna is Austria is a really famous example of has a very good public housing program, but they start very early on with getting the community members on board in places where they're going to put in a huge public housing development.

They actually will have a physical office that is staffed with a social worker, a counselor, a lawyer, a city planner, and other support staff that's in the community that people can walk into and basically say like, I have feelings about this. I feel really bad about this, or I'm really scared about how my neighborhood is going to change. And they can talk it through with a professional, and they also have all sorts of like really skilled facilitation in public engagement about, okay, we need to build this housing here. That's not up for debate.

But what is up for public input and what's up for compromise is how we build it, what we choose to keep, as and what we are willing to let go of to make it happen. And that kind of involvement is not really happening in the North American context, at least not in the mainstream. There are a few places that have experimented with it very successfully. Burnaby, where I live, actually has had a community assembly program or process that had something similar happen, and it's actually done very well in terms of having growth that people can live with.

And so, yeah, we really do need to start looking at. Are we asking the right questions, and are we starting this involvement early enough?

Jessica Barrett  15:04

I know that a lot of city planners are going to listen to this and go like, "Oh my gosh, like you want me to add this onto my workday already?" And people put me in a room where people are just going to yell at me. And the thing is, doing this upfront, giving people a chance to voice their grumbliness about change often is part of the process of getting them around to acceptance. They don't have to love it, but most people won't stand in the way once they feel heard and once they can understand where their input goes in the process.

And it what it ends up doing is actually making development go quicker once it is to the development stage because you're not getting sent back to the drawing board eight or ten times to tweak the density or the FSR or the community amenity contributions, and you're not having things like citizens that feel like they've been disenfranchised and so they're digging in their heels and putting restrictive covenants on their properties or suing the city or having a senior level of government step in and undo the legislation that the city just put in, like right now we're working at cross purposes a lot of the time because we're not taking the time to get it right at the ground floor in the first place.

Chuck Marohn  16:14

You've jarred this thing in my head. I feel like here in the U.S. you are in Canada. We have had this police discussion for a number of years. George Floyd, was the latest example in my state, and we had this conversation about, should we, in an extreme way, get rid of the police? Should we do? I feel like that conversation got very political and very crazy real quickly, but underneath it, there was some real questions about: Hey, if someone calls and they're having a mental health crisis, should we send out a mental health professional or should we send out a police officer?

If someone calls and they're they're having a heart attack, do we send the fire truck with the ladder and the all the stuff, or do we send out a team of EMTs. These are like real discussions that cities are having, not about like should we have police or not, or like geopolitical things, but like really like what is the best way to approach these things. I have thought for a long time that planners and other technical people actually can't solve these problems.

That what we need, and you described a team in Vienna. I'm gonna I'm gonna throw something out to you, and then let you react to it.

I've thought that our city halls need half the number of technical people, but probably three times as many people who do social work and conflict resolution, and just like literally know how to talk to people because most of the conflict we have is not the density number in the ordinance isn't right or the street width we don't know what it should be but it's actually people having conversations which is really hard for technical people to do maybe I'll just stop there and let you react to that because I do feel like you're getting at from a different direction something that we've been pushing on for a while, which is we want to make non-technical problems into technical problems because technical problems are easier for us to solve.

Jessica Barrett  18:19

Yeah, are technical problems easier for us to solve, or does it maybe pretend we can

Chuck Marohn  18:24

Solve? Yeah,

Jessica Barrett  18:25

Yeah. I don't know. I don't know if they are. I think that there is a belief that I think it's. I think it's clear that there's a. It's clear what the benchmark for success maybe is in a technical problem. Like yes, we greenlit this project, or no, we didn't. Whereas people are a lot more nebulous, and success is a lot more like you need to get 70% of the people on board. Is that success? I don't know. Depends who you ask, right?

But to your point about do we have the right people doing this work at cities? Yeah, urban planners are not trained in facilitation. They're not trained in mediation, and yet most often they are the ones who are leading the consultation and leading the public hearing. one of the reasons that I went to Vienna. Vienna gets talked about a lot in terms of like just the sheer number of housing that it can build and the financing of it all.

But I was really interested in one of the four pillars of Vienna system is social sustainability, and so they have the city has an army of 3000, maybe more, social workers that are on call to help people that are on call to help people get along in their social housing because they understand that if you have a system where someone has a lease that is a lifelong lease that they can grandfather to their children, that people are going to be living beside each other for sometimes generations.

If they can't get along or at least coexist peacefully together, the whole system breaks down. It just doesn't work, right? And so you need to have people who are community facilitators, who are sociologists, who are social workers, who are able to be literally on call. If you have a dispute with your neighbor in Vienna, you can call a hotline staffed by social workers, and they will come to your house and they will help you work out a solution with your neighbor.

I think we can be doing a lot more of that in North America. And is it should the city planner be the person conducting public hearings? I don't really know if they should or public input. I think someone who's more well versed and trained in facilitation in making sure that the quiet voices in the back or the renters or the single parents who are working three jobs and can't come to a 12-hour public hearing at City Hall, that their voices are heard, and yeah, I think that this work is a lot more valuable.

I think generally in our society we devalue emotional work as kind of as a blanket rule, but it this kind of thing that stands in the way of the technical people being able to look at a project and going, this pencils, let's greenlight it, right?

Chuck Marohn  21:08

Yeah, yeah, yeah. I think of like I spent some time in the Hasidic Jewish community in Brooklyn, New York, and it's fascinating to me because they live in extremely high density neighborhoods, and have social conflict because you're right on top of everybody else and all that. But there, it's resolved culturally because you have like a rabbi who's like, okay, you two, we need to figure this out, and like there's a there's a shared kind of like moral framework, and in a sense, you submit to a hierarchy that allows like those kind of like normal human things. I feel like as our society becomes more diverse and more, different people are living together in different places. It has occurred to me.

You almost need that overlay of, I'll just say, like interhu, interpersonal relationship. we're not building cities around churches anymore, and then the priest resolves social conflict within. We are a multicultural society. I feel like we're saying the same thing back and forth to each other. But am I? I'm saying it in a different way than you. Are we? Are we tracking on the same thing? Because I, I do feel like this is a big part of what's missing in the housing dialog.

Jessica Barrett  22:31

Absolutely, yeah. No, I, I think we're definitely speaking the same ideas, maybe in different language. But I think it actually was in my chat with you, Chuck, because you're in the book as well, about you mentioned that the term parish actually means to dwell beside community,

Chuck Marohn  22:50

Yeah,

Jessica Barrett  22:50

To dwell beside, right? And so, in North in a more secular, diverse culture and a more individualistic culture in North America, where a lot of our this is okay, we're going to detour to a little bit of a history lesson here. Go ahead, go ahead. I think this is great. So when we started living apart from each other in North America, let's say like the early 20th century, we started doing things like saying maybe overcrowded tenement houses aren't that great, and we want to put everybody in their perfect little, pitched roof, white picket fences.

In the post-war era, we started redesigning our neighborhoods so that we no longer had to interact with one another on a daily basis, and we started taking out these natural collection points, where we were all waiting for the trolley together, or walking down the sidewalk together, and then we see throughout that century the decline of people attending church services and taking part in other sort of citizenship, even leisure activities like bowling leagues. we got to bring bowling alone into this conversation.

Chuck Marohn  24:00

Well, even today, I can order my food on an app and not have to talk to a bank teller, and like you can see the human impulse, right?

Jessica Barrett  24:08

Yeah, and so we lost these ways where we had to get along with one another, and we also lost sort of the people who helped us get along with one another. And now, in our in our attempts to solve the housing crisis. We're starting to push us back together in close proximity. But what we've lost is the skill to live well together in close proximity.

And when I talk to people in North America about some of the places that I've been, so for the book, one of the places I went to was Harare, Zimbabwe, and I spent a lot of time in slum communities with, really impoverished people who are pooling their own money to do things like bring in infrastructure that they need to purchase land to eventually build high quality housing that they can live in together, and I feel like we have a tendency to look at places like. Vienna or like Harare or Berlin, where I also went, and say, well, they're just better at community than we are. There's something innate to their culture that they just they just do it, and we don't.

And what I found is that's just not true. What they do that we don't do is they work at it more, and they put in the social infrastructure to ensure that there are agreements in place, things that you can't do to a neighbor. You're not allowed to do just whatever you want. If you don't repay your loan to the community, then you'll be asked to rent out your house for a little while, or perhaps leave. you can't come to the community planning meeting and talk about which politician you're backing or which religion you're following, because that's not part of the mandate here.

What we're doing is building a community, and the community is the goal. And also, the standard of community, I think, is both too high and too low in North America in a way where we have this idea that anything short of holding hands with our neighbors and singing kumbaya means that we have failed at creating community, and also too low in that as soon as we hit a roadblock or a patch of gravel where it's like, ooh, I don't know, this person is a purple people eater, and I'm never going to see the world like they will, we throw up our hands and walk away and never talk to that person again, and we can't do that, right? Or we can do that, but that brings us to where we are now.

And the cultures who are finding ways through these big problems as a community, whether they're housing crisis or cost of living or climate change and getting through natural disasters and things like that, they have infrastructure in place to ensure that people have their social needs met, and that there is a code of conduct with how to be in community together. We've really let that go in North America through the sort of neoliberal individualism that we're all living under. This idea that if you have to compromise at all for someone else who lives around you, turn down your TV for the neighbor or whatever it is. You're giving up some sort of fundamental right that is central to who you are as a person, and we need to work to undo some of that.

And it does take work. Community doesn't just happen because you put people closer together. It happens because you put the structures in place to help them learn to live close together, and to help them value that.

Chuck Marohn  27:28

Feels like a part of this too is giving people the capacity to shape their own neighborhood. I feel like we have this idea that no neighborhood can be exempt from change, but no neighbor should experience radical change, and part of what is embodied in that idea is that your neighborhood is going to change, but we want you to have the agency of shaping it. I wonder how much of our dialog around NIMBYism and housing, and like I don't want any change in my neighborhood. Is just a byproduct of the agency people feel and what that change looks like, as opposed to like resisting all change at all time. I feel like it manifests that way because that's really the only option we're given, right?

Jessica Barrett  28:17

Yeah, it's interesting when I talk to my parents. Yeah, yeah. I have a lot of really, really good conversations with my parents who are in their 70s and 80s and live in suburban Edmonton, Alberta. Okay, and it's really interesting because my book talks a lot about the need to kind of change our communities and allow people to build, smaller, more nimble housing and things like that. Their takeaway was they're never leaving their suburban house; they're staying forever.

So, and I talked to them about it, and when I talked to my dad, who kind of understands on paper the whole issue with the housing crisis and the need to make room for more people and more different types of people, but he felt like if they were to redevelop their property into an eightplex, which I think the zoning currently allows for, that they would be betraying their neighbors because their neighbors would want it to be the same.

And so I think part of it is thinking about not just the people who are living around us now, but the people who will come after. Right? cities. The lifespan of a city is potentially 1000s of years. Right? The lifespan of a person is max 100, right? we're just not really thinking in terms of this long term. And when I pointed out to my parents that when they bought their house in the 90s, it was $220,000. They had four kids, and today adjusted for inflation, it should be about 450.

But that's not what the market's going for. It's closer to a million. Rather than thinking about only thinking about the people beside you now, you have to think about the next generation of me. Where was I at when I bought this house? And could someone in that position today afford to come into this neighborhood? So it's it's about expanding the idea.

Of who cities are for and whose needs need to be considered, and it's also I think back to my previous comments about doing more robust consultation because you don't know we all think we know that what people are feeling inside their homes, but you don't you don't know that the people next door aren't looking at their aging parents and thinking, God, I wish there was a way I could build like an access, accessible dwelling unit for them, and they could come and live with me. Or my hips are really starting to hurt. I don't know how much longer I'm going to be able to make it up these stairs. I wish there was a way. Or I'm lonely.

I wish there was a way I could live closer to my family or closer to in closer contact with the neighbors around me, you just don't know, and we don't create the space for people to have those conversations. Which is where I think things like community assembly models and a more empathetic approach to consultation and community planning can really take us far.

Chuck Marohn  30:58

You are critical of I'll just say profit-driven housing approaches, and I want to delve into that a little bit because obviously when it comes to financialization, I share your concern completely, and I feel like financialization has done wonders in bringing future abilities to pay for things into the present and making everything just vastly more expensive for everyone. I, I also think some of the stories you tell about speculation. It's bizarre to think of Vancouver, this really super high demand city with all these vacant homes in high price neighborhoods, which are basically just speculators waiting for the payout.

And to me, our system creates that, and it's abhorrent, right? It's just it's just really bad policy. But there is this part of like a profit-driven approach where people get rewarded for creating something that is needed for others, and I just wonder if you see a meaningful distinction between developers, builders, people who are working, in a neighborhood context to provide something that is needed, and doing it in response to demand at a profit, versus people who I feel like are working at a different layer of the economy and moving money around, dealing with interest rates, and it manifests locally in these kind of dysfunctional distortions that we see in housing on the ground. Is there is there a difference between those two in your mind?

I do feel like a lot of people just conflate those two and say profit bad, and I want to give you an opportunity to either say profit bad and like explain why, or say yes I see nuance and here's where I see that nuance is what I'm trying to get at.

Jessica Barrett  32:54

I'm critical of profit as the only motivator for building housing, and that's that, and I think that's that's where the nuance lies, right? And so we, there are a lot of Strong Towns advocates for the neighborhood developer, right? And that's and that's something that I've seen work really successfully, and work really unsuccessfully as well, right? And so the idea that we can get well-meaning people who want to do the right thing involved in building new housing, I think, has a lot of merit.

I think where we fall short of achieving that goal is when we when we use the carrot of profit as the only motivating factor. Right, you're going to choose this lot and you're going to build this housing for them because this is the thing that will net you the highest return, as opposed to, well, if we did consultation with the community, or you were going to build something for yourself and your family, or something, we might choose a different lot and a different design that's more socially minded and actually does respond to the needs of the community in a more responsive, more appropriate way, and perhaps it doesn't make as much money, but it still makes you some.

I think it's I think it's profit the highest margin as the only motivating factor is what I have a problem with, and I have a problem with taking sort of the that motivational rationale that multinational corporations, developers use when they're building, high-rise tower complex, and they're going, well, we're building 500 units of housing, so we're contributing to the solution. And then most of those units of housing are too expensive for the people who need that need them, and they're also not big enough, or people just don't want them who have the means to buy something to live their lives in, and so I really take issue with the idea that is that any and all housing is good housing.

I don't think it's necessarily the case, and I think we've seen that like fairly robustly at this point. Vancouver is still in a housing crisis; property values have plummeted. To the point where, our government is coming in to bail out condo builders because nobody is buying these condos. Because once investors left the market, once speculators left the market, nobody who had the money to buy a home they wanted to live in actually wanted to live in these, right?

And so, this is where I do think it is funny when over relied.

Chuck Marohn  35:22

You describe the luxury kitchen with no dining room, and I'm like, yeah, that is the epitome of the luxury condo unit, right?

Jessica Barrett  35:32

Yeah, what I have issue with is taking that same motivation and then trying to like overlay it and saying to the neighborhood developer who does want to do the right thing for their community, that you should take this same kind of approach. When I think that there are other things that we could be doing from a policy perspective, from a tax incentive perspective, from a financial perspective, to say we'll reward you for taking the financial risk and backing this, but it actually has to be part of a process that is actually going to provide the type of housing that people need and can afford, and we're not just going to rely on the trickle down filtering effect.

We're going to create the housing that people need right now, and there's a lot of ways to do that. there's this sort of like there's this vast middle ground between 100% publicly funded government run housing and completely private, for-profit housing that involves us communities, but there's just not a lot of pathways to allow people who, are a landowner in a in a place where they do have a lot of equity and they would maybe be willing to contribute that towards a community project.

But where are the community projects? Where is the support for the community projects? Where is the awareness and advertising of the community project? And where is the acceptance that having lived in your own home, paid off the mortgage, had a wonderful life in a neighborhood that you love, the ability to raise your children there is the payoff that you get for your home. You are not automatically entitled to an extra, let's say, two to $4 million on top of that because you happened to luck out in buying when you did.

Chuck Marohn  37:11

I feel like this conversation turns all these paradigms that we are know and are comfortable with on their head because I can hear some of the housing advocate pushing back on you and say, "Wow, what a privileged place to not have to worry about a house." And your book talks about your worries about housing. I think people should read it. I think there's also a pushback of when we build in those luxury apartments, it does filter down and give people more units, and I hear you pushing back against that. Have you experienced that kind of? I'm just going to say, like advocacy kind of pushback, and how does that how does that affected you and what you think about these things? You nodded a little bit.

I feel like I live in this world where I'm constantly getting bombarded by all sides who just have like the single solution to housing, and I'm like, this is such a complex issue. I feel like your book is dealing with like a great degree of the complexity. I'm imagining that you're you've gotten a little bit of hate because of it, is that is that fair? Am I tracking?

Jessica Barrett  38:24

Yeah, for sure. I think it is complex, and there is no single solution to housing. There isn't. the pushback I get. There's one really great one-star review on Goodreads talks about how this is just socialist NIMBY BS, and we shouldn't listen to it. And

Chuck Marohn  38:45

That's what I mean. Is like the one side is like you, Jessica, must be a commie, and on the other side, it must be you must be a trad wife. I'm like, what, what, what is going on here? Like, we are so weird about this topic.

Jessica Barrett  38:59

We are so weird about this topic. We are so weird about this topic. Yeah, like the one side is like it's not, it's not capitalist enough. Like I, how dare I talk about the fact that like maybe all of our housing policies don't need to exist to promote for profit housing. Some of them, maybe the balance. It's really about the balance, right? I'm not saying that market housing should disappear. I am questioning the amount of public money and public resources that go into creating for-profit housing, as opposed to non-market housing or break-even housing or alternatives that are meant to stay affordable not just for 10 or 15 years, but for generations.

And should our public money go into that? I think that's that's a fair question to ask. And on the other side, yeah, there is criticism from I am a homeowner. I started this journey writing this book and writing about housing as a renter. I am incredibly privileged. I have never, I am the first to admit that I am so lucky. Many people would be able to follow the pathway that I followed to find a home that works for me and my family, and that's part of the problem, right? I couldn't write this book if I was a renter facing eviction. if I was working three jobs trying to keep a roof over my head, and that is part of the problem, right?

When we don't have, we don't hear from those voices because they're not able to sit down and write a book for four years like I did.

Jessica Barrett  40:30

Does that mean I shouldn't write the book? I don't know. I think if I think it, I think someone needs to raise these things. Is am I the the end all and be all authority on the subject? Like absolutely not.

Chuck Marohn  40:41

No, but I'm really grateful because I do feel like as a journalist I watch my wife and my wife one of the struggles that she has I mean you opened with the idea of objectivity I feel like there's that there's also this sense of like if I live in a bubble I am not really understanding the world and able to report on it, and in a sense represent it back to people, and that will show up in my reporting. People will not value my reporting.

I do think that a lot of the housing advocacy tends to be a bubble, and often like a professional, almost in our society, the wealthier quintile, the a certain age, like there's a certain echo chamber bubble, and I do feel like when I was going through your book that you are expressing and relating to life conditions that are vastly outside that bubble, that are really, really important when it comes to housing.

Jessica Barrett  41:45

Thanks. I think I mean I really did want to do that, and part of the reason you asked me initially why did I write this book, and part of the reason was that I wanted. There's so much scholarship and so much research and good quality data around housing, both from the market perspective and the non-market perspective, and the housing advocacies and the build everywhere advocacies, but they're not really written for the general public. Back to journalistic objectivity, there's no way I could be objective in this because I need a house. I live in this system, you know. Like I'm a human being who requires shelter as a human right, just like every other human being.

And so by necessity, I'm part of this system. But what I did want to do was explore the system from as many angles as I could, because I did want to introduce people to try to pierce those bubbles a little bit. I tried really hard to have compassion for everybody I talked to, including developers, including wealthy boomers who have a lot of property and don't want to change, including the people that I talk to who are fighting for rent reform? I wanted to have a compassionate lens for everybody because I really do think we need to understand across the housing spectrum where people are at and where people are coming from as a first step.

I also wanted it to be accessible for people, which is why it's sort of written, sort of in the form of a memoir. you get to go step by step on my own housing journey, which was very troublesome and stressful. As I'm doing all of this research, because I found that there's so many academics and so many experts out there, and they're all talking to each other, and maybe they're talking to government, but they're not talking to you and me. They're not talking to people who are going, man. I just want to buy a house, right? Right. Why is this so hard? Or I don't. I don't really want to move across the country to buy a house. Why is this so hard? You know.

I and I want people to be more aware of the system that they are a part of because then they can make informed decisions about how they want that system to change.

Chuck Marohn  44:07

Let me ask you a final question then about change, because I feel like you've described a housing system that has stripped most people of agency. If you could identify like a first thing, not the solution, and not this one. Not about building more units, but of giving people power to shape their place and the place that they call home. What would that first step be?

Jessica Barrett  44:34

So my big takeaway in writing this book, and where for a long time I wasn't really sure how to end it, and I was like, I'm going to come up with like a list of policy recommendations. Like, yeah, it is a little snoozy. I don't know if that's where we really want to go. Am I going to, leave it on a cliffhanger? What am I going to do? I kept circling around this idea that like we need to know our neighbors more. Our neighbors. Because neighbors save the world, and I sat on that for a while and was like, "No, that can't be the end of the book. That's way too Pollyanna.

That can't. You're a serious journalist, Jessica. Like, get it together." And then I kept talking about it with people and talking about with my editor, and I was like, "I really think it's neighbors save the world." And she's like, "Yeah, let's go with that." And it is true because part of this discourse that we're in this very like bitter division on the YIMBYs and the NIMBYs and all of this is an inability to see other people's points of view, and also a cynical disbelief that people have the power to create the change they want to see. I know that sounds really idealistic, but it's true, and it's what I saw in Berlin. It's what I saw in Vienna. It's what I saw in Zimbabwe. It's what I see around me.

I live in a co-housing building that was built by a group of people who wanted to get together and pool their own resources and deal with all the city bureaucracy and all of the risk involved to make a community where I get to enjoy opening my door, letting my kid run out the door, and go to someone else's house and start playing there for the afternoon. I know where he is, and everybody knows he belongs, and he's safe.

I think we've sort of been conditioned, especially in North America, to the belief that like community is inconvenient, and our neighbors are nosy and impediments to our lives, and yet it's the getting together with neighbors, learning to work through conflict and come to a solution that we can all live with. We don't all have to love it, but we have to be able to live with it. That is the first step in getting us to move forward towards the solutions that we need, and so the one thing I would say for people to do is start talking to your neighbors.

Chuck Marohn  46:48

Neighbors save the world.

Jessica Barrett  46:50

Neighbor save the world.

Chuck Marohn  46:52

I love it. It's very good. It's funny. I don't know if you have ever seen, but we've actually recommended that many places too. You want a first step? Go talk to your neighbor. Like get to know them. It

Jessica Barrett  47:03

Is transformative. It is.

Chuck Marohn  47:05

Yeah, yeah, utterly. And it's and it's a

Jessica Barrett  47:06

Lower it's a it's a lower bar than people think, right? Like it's not necessarily that you have to invite them over for dinner. It's just saying hi. Or I think a lot of people are afraid of imposing on their neighbors, they don't want to be an inconvenience. But I've found that it's asking a favor of someone: Can you bring in my mail? Can you water my plants? Can you check on my cat?

That people are dying to be asked to do something for their neighbors because when you ask your neighbor to do something for you, it says that you trust them.

Chuck Marohn  47:39

Right,

Jessica Barrett  47:39

And people want to be trusted. They want to be seen as trustworthy, and that's the seed that goes towards all sorts of other great things that we can build.

Chuck Marohn  47:48

It's funny because you just jogged a memory. I had this guy I ran into once, and he was going on and on about he was kind of like a prepper, and he's like, I got this and this, and I've got this cabin out in the woods, and if things go bad, and he's like, "What do you What are you doing?" And I'm like, "I got neighbors,

Chuck Marohn  48:06

Yeah, like I got I got I got people around me that I care about and care about me, and they're not related to me. They're just neighbors. They're the people that I moved in next to, and I've gotten to know them, and they're pretty wonderful.

Jessica Barrett  48:18

And that's the thing, you know. Back to are we rational beings? Are we emotional beings? We can. We have both sides to us. We can debate that all day long. But what's not up for debate is that we are social beings. We are pack animals, and if we are not part of a community, we go a little funny, and maybe that's what brought us to where we are today.

Chuck Marohn  48:37

Jessica Barrett, the book is No Place Like Home: The Missing Key to Our Housing Crisis. I found it delightful and thoughtful, and I think you will too. I highly recommend it, Jessica. Thanks for being on the podcast. It's wonderful to speak to you.

Jessica Barrett  48:54

Thanks so much for having me. It's such a pleasure to be here.

Chuck Marohn  48:56

And thank you, everybody, for listening. Keep doing what you can to build a strong town. Take care.

Norm Van Eeden Petersman  49:04

This episode was produced by Strong Towns, a nonprofit movement for building financially resilient communities. If what you heard today matters to you, deepen your connection by becoming a Strong Towns member at strongtowns.org/membership.

‍

Additional Show Notes: