
You’ve finally found the lot where you’re going to build a fourplex. You’ve spent months working through the details to get the project ready. The plans are coming together, the zoning allows the building, and there are already people interested in renting units before construction even starts. Now you need financing to get the project off the ground. Before the bank decides how much it’s willing to lend, they need an estimate of what the property will be worth once construction is complete.
So the appraiser reviews your proposed building and looks for similar properties that have already sold to help estimate its value. You’re hoping that estimate is high enough to support the loan you need, because the bank will use it when deciding how much to lend you. If it comes in low, the bank may offer a smaller loan, and you’ll have to make up the difference. The problem is that the appraiser can only work with what’s already been built and sold nearby, and nobody’s built anything like your fourplex around here in a long time.
For Derek Leavitt, architect-developer, who has spent years developing small-scale housing, this is a familiar problem. When he spoke with researchers at UC Berkeley's Terner Center about building this type of housing, he summed it up simply: “Our comps are one hundred years old.”
We’ve spent years trying to make room for this kind of housing: rewriting zoning, pushing fourplexes into the residential building code, fighting HOA rules that ban anything but a single-family house. In a lot of places, that work is paying off. The bank still has to be convinced, though.
If you've ever bought or sold a house, you’ve probably been through an appraisal. Someone walks through the house, measures it, notes its condition, and then looks for similar homes nearby that have recently sold. Those are called comparable sales, or comps. They're one of the main ways an appraiser determines what a property is worth. When plenty of similar homes are selling nearby, finding comps is usually pretty straightforward.
Now try it with a fourplex on a street where nearly every lot holds a single-family house. When that kind of housing hasn't been built in a neighborhood for decades, finding comparable sales becomes much harder.
Fannie Mae, which sets appraisal requirements for the loans it purchases, requires at least three closed sales in the sales comparison approach. Those sales don't have to be identical, but when a fourplex is the only one of its kind in the area, finding three that reflect its market value can be difficult. The number the appraiser lands on can decide whether the project can move forward financially.
A 2025 Missing Middle Housing Toolkit for the Chicago region illustrates this problem with an example from Arlington Heights, Illinois. The toolkit's comparison shows a detached home and a duplex with recent sale dates, but the fourplex comparable has no sale date listed. That leaves appraisers looking for other ways to establish its value.
For two- to four-unit properties, Fannie Mae also requires the income approach, which estimates value from the rent the units could bring in. The cost approach can also help with new or proposed construction by looking at the value of the land and what it would cost to build the property today. These approaches give the appraiser more to work with, but they don't replace the need for comparable sales.
At two roundtables the Terner Center held in 2022, developers told researchers that appraisers struggled to find comparable projects, and sometimes didn’t understand the housing type. That lack of familiarity could lead to lower valuations, limiting how much a developer could borrow.
Lenders have reasons to be nervous. If comparable properties sell for much less than the loan amount and the borrower defaults, the bank could take a loss when it has to resell the property. The Terner brief also found that national banks and large equity sources mostly passed on missing middle projects. The deals looked too small, and a housing type with no track record looked risky.
South Bend, Indiana, describes this problem in its Small Scale Developer Handbook. City officials say the appraisal gap affects nearly every tract in the city, with neighborhoods around Notre Dame as the main exception. In areas with a lot of vacant lots, existing buildings are often valued below what it would cost to replace them today. The comps may exist. They just reflect a different era. That’s a different version of the problem than in a city where values are high, and nothing like a fourplex has sold. In South Bend, the comps are there, and they’re low. The builder still ends up in the same place: an appraisal that doesn’t cover what it costs to build.
It’s easier to see with real numbers. CDFI Friendly South Bend walks through a typical case on their website. The example starts with a property that costs $190,000 to buy and rehab. The appraisal comes in at $205,000. A typical loan covers 75% of the appraisal, or $153,750, which leaves about $36,000 the developer has to cover. The example is about buying and rehabbing an existing property, not building a fourplex from scratch, but the math is similar. Even with an appraisal that's $15,000 above the project cost, the developer still has to write a check to cover the difference.
So some developers build the first one themselves. They carry the upfront cost with no comps to lean on, and they hope that first sale makes the next loan easier. Leavitt put it simply: “We have to create our own comps.”
Once the first building is finished and sold, there's finally a recent sale on the books. The builder who went first paid for that proof in equity and delays. A year later, another builder with a similar lot and a similar plan has a nearby sale to bring to the appraiser. The first building on a block had to establish a track record that the next one can build on.
So what can cities and local lenders do while the comps are still missing?
South Bend has started by lowering some of the costs developers face before construction. The city has offered free pre-approved building plans since 2022. For a house or duplex, that means skipping most of the design bill. It also waives the system development fee for infill projects with five or fewer units. That fee is another expense a developer has to cover before the building even exists, and it’s cash the bank won’t lend.
The city also provides sample pro forma templates, so a first-time builder can work through the numbers before sitting down with a lender. Between the plans, the fee waiver, and the templates, the first builder spends less before breaking ground and makes a stronger case to the bank. These tools help lower the cost of getting started, but they don't create comparable sales or solve the appraisal gap. If the appraisal can’t come up, the cost can come down.
The city has also worked with local partners to help developers get financing. CDFI Friendly South Bend is a nonprofit that connects local borrowers with community development financial institutions, or CDFIs. These are mission-driven financial institutions that provide financing in low-income and economically distressed communities, particularly to borrowers and businesses that may have fewer options through traditional lenders.
Here’s how it works: when a renovated property appraises below what it cost to buy and rehab, the program uses a capital fund to cover the equity shortfall, without adding debt for the developer. The money is returned within five years and put toward the next community project. The program can step in when the appraisal falls short, as long as the property's income is still enough to cover its debt payments. They developed the program with the City of South Bend, Notre Dame Federal Credit Union, and other local funders. Cinnaire, a housing-focused CDFI, provides the lines of credit developers use to purchase and rehab properties.
It's a small program. The website reports 10 funded community developments, 23 improved units of affordable housing, and $280,000 in capital fund use. This example description describes buying and rehabbing existing properties, not new construction. Still, it shows how local partners can help close a financing gap that a traditional loan may leave behind. The important part is that the program isn't asking the developer to take on another loan to make up the difference. It uses a shared pool of capital to cover the gap, then recycles that money once it's returned. That gives the next project a chance to use the same funding instead of requiring a new pot of money each time.
The National Association of Home Builders' June 2026 financing guide describes a few ways lenders and public partners could make that support go further. Instead of evaluating every small project on its own, lenders could look at a group of projects together. For projects built in phases, revolving loans could let developers move from one phase to the next without starting a new application each time. None of this makes the first fourplex easy. Free plans, a waived fee, and a lender willing to look at one small building just make it less of a gamble. The comps only show up after someone takes it.
Somewhere right now, a builder is looking at an appraisal number and doing the math on whether to keep going. The lot is bought. The plans are done. The zoning, finally, says yes. What they're waiting on is proof, and the only way to get it is to build the thing that proves it. If they do build it, the next person gets to ask the appraiser an easier question. They'll point down the street, and the appraiser will finally have somewhere to look.
[[divider]]
Want to learn more? Our Housing-Ready City strategy offers 6 local financing tools to allow developers and builders to overcome the financing barriers that prevent needed housing from being built.
Strong Towns columnist Sheinya Joseph is an architectural designer and urbanist passionate about creating more equitable, people-centered communities. She serves as President of Emerging New Urbanists, a nonprofit organization dedicated to supporting the next generation of city builders. Her interests lie at the intersection of architecture, urban planning, and public policy.